The Missing Middle Behind India's Battery Challenge: A Response to Swarajya
Raghavan Rao's article in Swarajya on Indian conglomerates' battery retreat, published yesterday, is sharp and well-documented. The reactions to the article post and thread on X are predominantly concerned and critical, aligning with the post's warning about India's battery/EV sector becoming "born dependent" on China (especially for cells, chemistry, and upstream materials). Many users view it as a cautionary tale of policy execution gaps, corporate risk-aversion, and geopolitical vulnerability — shifting from petroleum import dependence to battery-material import dependence. The article's core observation is accurate: companies that announced battery sovereignty ambitions between 2021 and 2023 have, by 2026, largely settled into assembling Chinese cells into Indian enclosures. The contrast with Korean and Japanese firms — who paired technology licensing with sustained, long-horizon R&D investment and gradually converted external knowledge into indig...