From Talent Debate to System Design: Rethinking India's Talent Migration Question
India’s long-running debate over “brain drain" has returned in a new form. This time, it is not about whether talent leaves—but whether it should come back. On 27 April, tech entrepreneur Sridhar Vembu, in an open letter in X, appealed to Indian-Americans to return home to build India's technological strength and industrial sovereignty, arguing that the political environment in USA is no longer suitable to them. On 28 April, in US-based tech entrepreneur Vivek Wadhwa, in a response article in Moneycontrol, argued that India no longer needs its diaspora in the way Vembu appeals for and that India’s internal momentum is now sufficient rebuild the country. Both perspectives are thoughtful, and both capture important aspects of India’s evolving position in the world. But they are also focused on a question that is, ultimately, secondary: Should Indians abroad return? The more fundamental question is simpler—and more consequential: What kind of country is India becoming for those...